Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion GroupsBoatsPaddle BoatsSailingCruisingBuildingElectronics
Related Topics
CarsMotorcyclesMore Topics ...

Boat Forum / Building / September 2007



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Polyester vs Epoxy resin for dinghy/kayak construction?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
koosvander@gmail.com - 20 Aug 2007 20:43 GMT
I am planning to build a hard dodger for my sailboat. I'm fairly
mechanically skilled, and accustomed to working with my hands, but
have never worked with fiberglass repair/construction.

So I'm planning to make a dinghy or kayak before I make the dodger, to
gain some experience.

So far I like the Foamee Glen-L dinghy, it's a foam and fiberglass
construction, which I like because of the fair lines (good for
dodger). Search the 'net for links, I'm not promoting it..

Two questions..

What are the relative merits of polyester resin vs epoxy resin?

Any recommendations on other dingy plans or kayak plans which have
smooth lines instead of the hard corners seen with plywood
construction?

Thanks,
-Koos
Paul Oman - 20 Aug 2007 21:01 GMT
>I am planning to build a hard dodger for my sailboat. I'm fairly
>mechanically skilled, and accustomed to working with my hands, but
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
>
>  

Epoxy resins don't dissolve foam but I believe  polyester resins do.
Your options would seem to be a small boat or a puddle of  foam goo.

paul oman
progressive epoxy polymers
koosvander@gmail.com - 20 Aug 2007 21:31 GMT
> koosvan...@gmail.com wrote:
> >I am planning to build a hard dodger for my sailboat. I'm fairly
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
> paul oman
> progressive epoxy polymers

Very good! That's helps me with that question.

Anyone with suggestions on alternate plans, dinghy or kayak with
smooth lines?

Thanks,
-Koos.
Bill - 20 Aug 2007 22:44 GMT
> > koosvan...@gmail.com wrote:
> > >I am planning to build a hard dodger for my sailboat. I'm fairly
[quoted text clipped - 34 lines]
>
> - Show quoted text -

I use this site for info on constructions methods for my outrigger
canoe project.  He has a few plywood kayak designs.

http://oneoceankayaks.com/stitchglue/stitchkayaks.htm
Meindert Sprang - 21 Aug 2007 09:26 GMT
> Anyone with suggestions on alternate plans, dinghy or kayak with
> smooth lines?

Ian Oughtred's Puffin?

See www.customware.nl/boats
And that one is entirely glued with epoxy.

Meindert
koosvander@gmail.com - 21 Aug 2007 16:47 GMT
On Aug 21, 1:26 am, "Meindert Sprang" <m...@NOJUNKcustomORSPAMware.nl>
wrote:

> Ian Oughtred's Puffin?
>
> Seewww.customware.nl/boats
> And that one is entirely glued with epoxy.
>
> Meindert

That's a beautiful dinghy!

Perhaps I should make one like that, for the experience. I'm doing
this as a prelude to making a hard dodger on my sailboat. It won't be
a lapstrake dodger, but perhaps the skills will be beneficial. I don't
know if I need to invest so much time into woodwork skills.. Perhaps I
do?

I really plan to make a fiberglass hard dodger and bimini, with smooth
lines, hard windows, and some wood trim.

-Koos.
OldNick - 24 Aug 2007 00:27 GMT
That;s not quite correct. Polyester dissolves some foams; notably
styrene. PVC foam and urethane foam are not affected. PVC foam is the
best for strength and longevity, but not cheap. It can also be used to
make compound (smooth) lines with a little effort.

>> Epoxy resins don't dissolve foam but I believe  polyester resins do.
>> Your options would seem to be a small boat or a puddle of  foam goo.
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>Thanks,
>-Koos.

Human bevaviour: Bestiality with a brain
Lew Hodgett - 20 Aug 2007 23:09 GMT
> What are the relative merits of polyester resin vs epoxy resin?

Trying to compare polyester and woven roving to epoxy and knitted
glass is like trying to compare oranges and apples.

Both are "fiberglass" laminates, but the similarity ends there.

About the best you get is 35%glass/65%resin using woven roving, mat,
and polyester.

OTOH, it is quite common to get a 50%glass/50%resin using knitted
glass and epoxy. This laminate does not require any mat.

Bottom line....................

Polyester/roving produces a rather brittle, heavy laminate.

Epoxy/knitted glass produces a more ductile, lighter weight laminate.

Pound for pound, polyester and woven roving cost less per pound, but
you use more pounds, so the cost differences tend to disappear.

Epoxy, knitted glass and a 1/2" Airex foam core would produce a very
light weight, bullet proof, dinghy or kayak.

Just remember three things.

1)You will buy a commercial dinghy for less money than you will spend
to build one.

2)You build one because you want to do it.

3)Once you use epoxy and knitted glass, you will never consider
polyester again.

Lew
cavelamb himself - 20 Aug 2007 23:47 GMT
snip

> 3)Once you use epoxy and knitted glass, you will never consider
> polyester again.
>
> Lew

Amen, brudder!
koosvander@gmail.com - 21 Aug 2007 16:42 GMT
> 3)Once you use epoxy and knitted glass, you will never consider
> polyester again.
>
> Lew

Thanks Lew, I have worked with epoxy before, rebuilding a hatch for my
son's 24-foot sailboat.

I don't know why I though that polyester would be an option, just
ignorance I suppose.. Thus my question..

Best wishes,
-Koos.
Lew Hodgett - 20 Aug 2007 23:12 GMT
> What are the relative merits of polyester resin vs epoxy resin?

Trying to compare polyester and woven roving to epoxy and knitted
glass is like trying to compare oranges and apples.

Both are "fiberglass" laminates, but the similarity ends there.

About the best you get is 35%glass/65%resin using woven roving, mat,
and polyester.

OTOH, it is quite common to get a 50%glass/50%resin using knitted
glass and epoxy. This laminate does not require any mat.

Bottom line....................

Polyester/roving produces a rather brittle, heavy laminate.

Epoxy/knitted glass produces a more ductile, lighter weight laminate.

Pound for pound, polyester and woven roving cost less per pound, but
you use more pounds, so the cost differences tend to disappear.

Epoxy, knitted glass and a 1/2" Airex foam core would produce a very
light weight, bullet proof, dinghy or kayak.

Just remember three things.

1)You will buy a commercial dinghy for less money than you will spend
to build one.

2)You build one because you want to do it.

3)Once you use epoxy and knitted glass, you will never consider
polyester again.

Lew
Crandall - 22 Aug 2007 21:04 GMT
"Lew
> Polyester/roving produces a rather brittle, heavy laminate.
> Epoxy/knitted glass produces a more ductile, lighter weight laminate.
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> 3)Once you use epoxy and knitted glass, you will never consider
> polyester again.

Lew is right on every particular.
mike.e.worrall@abc.com - 23 Aug 2007 04:06 GMT
> Lew is right on every particular.

Yes... but.  Lew's Knitted glass - when bought in 'roll' quantites is
about a dollar-a-pound more expensive than woven roving.  Traditional
thinking is that woven fabric is used primarily with fiberglass 'mat'
in a polyester layup, one between the other.  The basic reason for
this is that the woven, i.e. "over, under, repeat" nature of the w.r.
causes "hollows" where the 'high' strands cross-over the 'low' strands
of glass.  The mat (in addition to providing significant bulk, and
sucking up a lot of resin) is thought to "tie" the woven layers
together, by bridging these 'hollows.'

Now, in a large epoxy resin layup one can significantly reduce the
cost, while maintaining adequate strength by continuing to use woven-
roving.  The mat is forsaken in favor of a slurry of milled fibers and
a little cab-o-sil mixed to a 'light cream' consistency.  That is,
layer of w.r. wet out with straight epoxy.  Squeege.  Trowel in a
slurry of epoxy / milled fibers / cab-o-sil, then next layer of w.r.
Finish wet-out with straight epoxy. Squeege.  Repeat.

The milled fiber + cab-o-sil slurry is filling the hollows and
providing a tie for the next layer of woven fabric.  A 10 lb bag of
cab-o-sil is like way cheap, and will last the entire project.  A 50
lb bag of milled fibers is similarly inexpensive.

And, becuase we've eliminated the mat, resin-to-glass ratio's of 50 /
50 are easily achived.

So, in a large project where cost is a concern my belief is that one
ought not write-off woven roving as being a suitable material.

MW
Lew Hodgett - 23 Aug 2007 09:01 GMT
> > Lew is right on every particular.
>
[quoted text clipped - 26 lines]
> So, in a large project where cost is a concern my belief is that one
> ought not write-off woven roving as being a suitable material.

About the only thing missing from the above is a little spit and some
baling wire.

Lew
Lew Hodgett - 21 Aug 2007 01:18 GMT
> What are the relative merits of polyester resin vs epoxy resin?

Trying to compare polyester and woven roving to epoxy and knitted
glass is like trying to compare oranges and apples.

Both are "fiberglass" laminates, but the similarity ends there.

About the best you get is 35%glass/65%resin using woven roving, mat,
and polyester.

OTOH, it is quite common to get a 50%glass/50%resin using knitted
glass and epoxy. This laminate does not require any mat.

Bottom line....................

Polyester/roving produces a rather brittle, heavy laminate.

Epoxy/knitted glass produces a more ductile, lighter weight laminate.

Pound for pound, polyester and woven roving cost less per pound, but
you use more pounds, so the cost differences tend to disappear.

Epoxy, knitted glass and a 1/2" Airex foam core would produce a very
light weight, bullet proof, dinghy or kayak.

Just remember three things.

1)You will buy a commercial dinghy for less money than you will spend
to build one.

2)You build one because you want to do it.

3)Once you use epoxy and knitted glass, you will never consider
polyester again.

Lew
justwaitafrekinminute@gmail.com - 21 Aug 2007 01:38 GMT
> 3)Once you use epoxy and knitted glass, you will never consider
> polyester again.
>
> Lew

You got that right!!
Richard Casady - 21 Aug 2007 19:18 GMT
Did you know that you seem to have posted three copies of the same
message? I don't really mind all that much, but I thought you might
like to know.

Casady
Lew Hodgett - 21 Aug 2007 19:58 GMT
> Did you know that you seem to have posted three copies of the same
> message?

After the fact, yes.

It was my problem.

Lew
OldNick - 24 Aug 2007 00:30 GMT
On Tue, 21 Aug 2007 11:58:39 -0700, "Lew Hodgett"
<lewhodgett@earthlink.net> wrote stuff
and I replied:

>> Did you know that you seem to have posted three copies of the same
>> message?
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
>Lew

Hey! If you mean what you say, get out there and _say_ it, man! <G>
Human bevaviour: Bestiality with a brain
Toller - 07 Sep 2007 22:19 GMT
>> What are the relative merits of polyester resin vs epoxy resin?
>
[quoted text clipped - 30 lines]
> 3)Once you use epoxy and knitted glass, you will never consider
> polyester again.

I have never actually built anything with fg, but have done numerous
repairs.
I have always used woven cloth with epoxy, and haven't heard the term
"knitted" before.
A google search showed it was the same as unidirection fabric.  Is that
correct, or is knitted something else?
Lew Hodgett - 07 Sep 2007 22:56 GMT
> I have never actually built anything with fg, but have done numerous
> repairs.
> I have always used woven cloth with epoxy, and haven't heard the term
> "knitted" before.
> A google search showed it was the same as unidirection fabric.  Is that
> correct, or is knitted something else?

Woven fabric looks like a burlap bag, a very coarse weave.

Knitted fabric looks like suit fabric, very fine, tightly knitted
fabric.

Do a Google for Knytex, then DB170.

That will get you to a double bias (+/-45), 17 oz/sq yard material.

It is about all I use these days.

There are also what are known as "Uni" fabrics which have the fiber
oriented either 0 or 90 degrees to the run of the roll.

Lew
Conlin - 29 Sep 2007 16:45 GMT
Knitted glass consists of two or more layers of unidirectional glass which
are knitted together.  It's available with the glass at 0 and 90 degrees and
with the glass at +-45 degrees.  It is less expensive per pound than glasss
fabric.  Because the fibers are not crimped by weaving, it's stronger and,
for a given glass content, thinner and therefore it needs less epoxy to
fill.  So, for structural purposes, it's superior to mat & roving and to
cloth.  It often does not finish as smooth as cloth, so a top laminate of
cloth is a good way to finish .

>>> What are the relative merits of polyester resin vs epoxy resin?
>>
[quoted text clipped - 37 lines]
> A google search showed it was the same as unidirection fabric.  Is that
> correct, or is knitted something else?
Richard Casady - 21 Aug 2007 19:13 GMT
>What are the relative merits of polyester resin vs epoxy resin?
I think epoxy is somewhat stronger, and kayaks are famous for hitting
rocks. For a dingy that may not matter as much. I heard epoxy costs
more, but if you end up with a lot of work in it, why end up with
something second rate.

Casady
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.